Half of 36 States Insolvent: An Issue for the New Candidates By Pius Adesanmi

Increasingly, you hear a segment of the commentariat scream that restructuring in Nigeria is a complex set of issues and problems that should be nuanced. Such commentators often ask: what is restructuring? What exactly are we restructuring? They then berate those who have “a simplistic, financial understanding of the issue”.

Well, I have a simplistic, financial understanding of the issue. Insofar as Nigeria is concerned, every other nuance, every other understanding of restructuring, sits on that one foundation of the economic and the financial side of things. I don’t understand why folks are trying to muddy the waters by adding layers of other complex issues.

The narrative is simple and we should not make it complex. Nigeria as is has only one feeding bottle. The cerelac in the feeding bottle is disproportionately produced by certain sections of the country. Another section of the country has disproportionately controlled this singular feeding bottle, has been extremely rude and arrogant about it, and has convinced herself that she has a manifest destiny to control the feeding bottle. Manifest Destiny in political science has a local name in Nigeria: born to rule mentality.

We are saying there is the necessity of creating numerous other feeding bottles. We are saying: hold your own feeding bottle and find the cerelac to put in it and do whatever you please. Every province in Canada is OYO. You are on your own with your feeding bottle and your cerelac. You pay something to Ottawa. Dazzol.

Because of this arrangement, you hardly ever see provincial premiers in Ottawa. What are you coming to do in the Federal capital? It would be odd, totally strange to see the Premier of British Columbia or Alberta making frequent stops in Ottawa.

With very few exceptions, the state capital is a secondary home of a Nigerian governor. Abuja is their permanent home address. They must constantly go and grovel in Aso Rock. Yahaya Bello of Kogi, Nasir El Rufai of Kaduna, Abdulaziz Yari of Zamfara, and Rochas Okorocha of Imo have taken Abuja junkets to a disgraceful level. They don’t even pretend to have any dignity.

If you look at the newly-released Economic Confidential Annual State Viability Index (ASVI) 2017, you will understand that those who are saying there is more to restructuring than fiscal and economic federalism are just wasting our time and confusing us. Every other issue is secondary to genuine fiscal federalism as far as I am concerned.

According to the 2017 ASVI, 17 of Nigeria’s 36 states are insolvent, a.k.a not viable. That is half the states in the country! There are of course levels to insolvency. Of the 17 insolvent states, here are those who would absolutely not be able to survive without the federal feeding bottle: Bauchi, Yobe, Borno, Kebbi, Katsina, and Jigawa.

It should not be rocket science why the north, writ large, is the traditional home of opposition to fiscal federalism alias restructuring.

If you want to understand the journey to this conundrum, you have to look at the total history of state agitation in Nigeria, especially in the period between the transition from 19 to 36 states. You must also look at the mentality informing current agitation for more states.

If you examine the archives, you will discover that at no time in Nigeria’s history has agitation for and creation of more states been ever informed by considerations of viability because Nigeria operates a philosophy and a political system featuring an overcentralized feeding system from only one source – that is prebendalism.

The discontent leading to agitation of a new state is always fed by ethnicity (we are Yewa, we want a Yewa state) or religion (we are a Christian minority in southern Kaduna, we want a state), never by viability.

The ethnic and religious side of this discontent is then fed by an overriding desire to have a better stake in the distribution from the centre. In other words, you want states not because they are viable but because you want to bring the feeding bottle pipelines closer to you.

In this sort of atmosphere, the longer you have controlled the centre, the more time you have had to carve indigent states and thus saddle your own geo-political zone with a disproportionate concentration of indigent and unviable states, totally dependent on the centre.

This is essentially where we are today. And this is the nut we must ask Kingsley Moghalu and other new candidates to address. I know that Atiku went to London to address restructuring but he is not a candidate I am adducing any credibility to. I am focusing, as you know, on the new, paradigm shift candidates.

However, Atiku did churn out the usual cliched orthodoxy about restructuring in London. Atiku’s speech does not tell us how he proposes to change the predominant mindset about restructuring in his own part of the country. What does Moghalu have to offer beyond that? In essence, how do you bring the north on board the train of genuine fiscal federalism when the reality is that too many states yonder are unviable?

Elsewhere, I have proposed a comprehensive approach to this matter but I am not going to mention it here because Moghalu and the other new candidates should be pressed on it. They should be supplying the answers for vetting.

Written By
Prof Pius Adesanmi

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Some more Related News you might be interested in....

Outrage as Oscars Disqualifies Genevieve’s LionHeart For Having Too Much English

GenevieveLionheart

Genevieve’s Lionheart, Nigeria’s submission for the Oscars, has been disqualified by the Oscars Board for having “too much English in it,”. According to The Wrap, Nigeria’s Lionheart has been disqualified from the 92nd Academy Awards race. The film, directed by and starring Genevieve Nnaji, was vying for a spot in the Best International Feature Film […] Read more

G-Worldwide Slams Kizz Daniel with a N500M Lawsuit

Kizz Daniel

Nigerian singer, Kizz Daniel embroiled in a contractual dispute with his then-record label, G Worldwide has taken another ugly turn. The issue was his desire to breach the terms of his contract and exit the label without fulfilling the terms of his contract. As a result of the dispute, an injunction prevented him from performing […] Read more

Davido Splash N36 million On Customized Jewelry for Zlatan

Davido 30BG

Nigerian singer, songwriter and record producer, David Adedeji Adeleke aka Davido, splash the sum of $100K (N36million) to purchase customised jewelries for Zlatan Ibile, Skibii and seven other members of his 30BG (30billion gang). The singer rewarded the Nigerian rapper, songwriter and dancer Omoniyi Temidayo Raphael aka Zlatan Ibile, who is also in the United […] Read more

Tiwa Savage’s 49-99 appears On New York Times Square Billboard

TiwaSavage4499

Tiwa Savage‘s new single 44-99 was promoted on the New York Times Square Bill Board. Excited Tiwa could not hold her joy as she shared the news with her 8 million followers. “New York Times Square.We did say WORLDWIDE release 😝#49-99 New Single out now watch the visuals on YouTube .Huge shoutout to @youtubemusic ❤️ […] Read more

BBNaija 2019: “If Tacha Doesn’t Win, I Will give her The Prize Money”- Peter Okoye

PeterOKoye

Peter Okoye, formerly of the P Square famous musical group, has joined celebrities to support housemates in the 2019 Big Brother Naija. He expressed support for the controversial housemate Tacha, declaring he would give her the ₦ 60m prize money should she fail to win the show. Peter Okoye Instagram In July, he declared support […] Read more

Sonia La Reina Announces Her Divorced With Ik Ogbonna

SoniaLareina-IkOgbonna

Sonia La Reina has announced that her and Nollywood actor Ik Ogbonna have divorced.The Colombian model made this known via her Instagram page on Thursday, August 8, 2019. According to her, Ik Ogbonna helped shape herself and she is thankful. The couple got engaged in 2015 and have a Son together. She deleted all her previous pictures […] Read more

// End of script for the slider